A ten doesn’t mean a game never got on your nerves. In HUDWire’s count at 9:30 a.m. CET on November 19, 120 of the 150 scored reviews on Metacritic’s PS5 page gave GTA 6 top marks. That’s a snapshot for one platform. Four of those reviews help explain how critics could land on a perfect score without having a frictionless time.
The city gets your attention. The couple gives you a reason to stay.
VGC saw Leonida build on the detail and interactivity of Red Dead Redemption 2, while turning Rockstar’s usual satire of the American Dream into a personal story. The Guardian found both sides compelling: a city that responds in unexpected ways and two leads whose fate matters once the mayhem dies down. Game Informer and Push Square also saw the relationship as a source of emotional weight.

The ten came with caveats.
VGC reported occasional frame-rate drops in dense areas. Push Square missed a 60 fps option and felt the story dragged in places. Game Informer found some missions left little room to improvise, though that structure helped maintain the pace. The Guardian described how complicated controls and unpredictable systems could turn a simple intention into a frustrating mess.
Here’s the interesting part: the city that sometimes gets in the way of your plans is also the one that makes you want to go off script. And when the campaign calls you back, these critics wanted to see what happened to the two people at its center. That mattered more than the rough edges.
Watch IGN’s review
Watch IGN’s review on YouTube (may contain spoilers). · IGN / Luke Reilly.
Cover: official Jason and Lucia artwork. Rockstar Games.
