An open-world game can give you a whole city and still take its time handing over the keys. Three reviews from the lower end of GTA 6’s launch scores show why that matters. None thought the game was bad.
80 · ScreenHub: freedom on a timer

Alice Clarke gave GTA 6 four stars out of five. The opening felt so closely guided that she missed the freedom to cause trouble. Chapter Three was the turning point in her playthrough: the story found momentum and side activities gave her room to choose. That didn’t erase the uneven writing or the stretches she felt needed trimming.
90 · Noisy Pixel: chaos needs consequences
Orpheus Joshua gave it a 9/10 and recommends it. Police responses didn’t always feel proportionate to him, and skipping a section after repeated failures could cheapen the satisfaction of getting through a tough encounter. Leonida sold him on the details, if not always on how it reacted to him.
90 · TheSixthAxis: not every mission needs to top the last
Aran Suddi also gave it 9/10 and found missions that made room for improvisation. After damaging a plane he was supposed to return, he got a smaller payout instead of a failure screen. His problem was with the plot: repeatedly upping the stakes diluted the impact of moments that already landed.
How we chose the reviews
In HUDWire’s tally of Metacritic’s PS5 scores at 9:30 a.m. CET on November 19, 2026, one review scored 80 and ten scored 90. These two 90s were chosen for their different arguments, not as an outright second or third place.
Mais FPS take
One critic wants freedom sooner, another wants choices to carry more weight, and a third shows the game can accommodate improvisation. A larger map doesn’t solve any of those problems on its own.
Sources
ScreenHub (4/5) · Noisy Pixel (9/10) · TheSixthAxis (9/10) · HUDWire · Metacritic (PS5)
Cover: official artwork by Rockstar Games.
