2 min read

GTA 6 from 80 to 100: Why critics split over the opening

Both launch-day aggregates hit 99. In the reviews, a 20-point gap begins with one shared observation: some missions stay firmly on rails.

Jason e Lucia num terraço com vista para Vice City.
Jason e Lucia em GTA VI. Arte oficial: Rockstar Games/Divulgação.

On November 19, Metacritic showed 99/100 on PS5 (150 critic ratings in its score breakdown) and the same 99 on Xbox Series X (14). OpenCritic showed a 99 Top Critic Average, 99% recommending and 89 review listings. These are launch-day critic snapshots, not player scores, and the samples differ.

The 80: Freedom took its time

Jason and Lucia in an official GTA VI image
Official image: Rockstar Games (promotional image).

On November 18, ScreenHub’s Alice Clarke gave the game 4 out of 5 stars, or 80 on a 100-point scale. Playing on PS5 Pro, she found the opening slow and restrictive, with too little room for mischief and uneven writing. For her, the game became more fun and the story more engaging around Chapter Three, roughly 25 hours into her playthrough. That is her experience, not a universal timer, and this was not a negative review: she praised the performances and the world’s small details.

The 100: Same rails, different result

In his November 18 Game Informer review, Outrageous Fortune, Matt Miller gave it 10/10 on PS5. He too found that many missions prescribed where to go and what to do. For Miller, that direction kept the pace up and made the sequences land. Jason and Lucia’s relationship and the care lavished on Leonida’s details helped make his case for a 10.

Six reviews to compare

Game Informer, Matt Miller: 10/10 · IGN, Luke Reilly: 10/10 · The Guardian, Keza MacDonald: 5/5 · Push Square, Sammy Barker: 10/10 · TheSixthAxis, Aran Suddi: 9/10 · ScreenHub, Alice Clarke: 4/5. That is the range of these six selected reviews, not a census of every score worldwide.

Mais FPS take

The disagreement isn’t about whether GTA 6 puts missions on rails. It’s whether you want the game to hand you the wheel immediately or choose part of the route.

Sources

Metacritic: PS5 · Metacritic: Xbox Series X · OpenCritic: GTA VI

Video: Game Informer — Matt Miller

Cover: official artwork by Rockstar Games.

Watch on YouTube

Join the conversation

O seu endereço de e-mail não será publicado. Campos obrigatórios são marcados com *

Este site utiliza o Akismet para reduzir spam. Saiba como seus dados em comentários são processados.